So you may have read the earlier post which compared the iPhone and the Palm Pre, but since so many of you commented I’ve decided to make a follow up to that article, however now the iPhone 3GS has been announced it will take the 3G’s place in the comparison.
Some of you thought my points didn’t make much sense or didn’t agree with them so here’s a second go round with easier explanation.
iPhone 3GS – 3 Megapixel Camera with 30fps VGA Video w/ Auto-Focus & Auto-Macro.
Palm Pre – 3 Megapixel Camera with LED Flash and no video as of yet.
From a camera stand point the iPhone, is now ahead of the Pre, with the ability to record 30fps VGA Video. Also the iPhone 3GS comes with Auto-Focus & Auto-Macro.
iPhone 3GS – 16GB / 32GB non-expandable
Palm Pre – 8GB non-expandable
The iPhone now has more storage than the Pre and the current 3G has the same storage capacity.
iPhone 3GS – On-Screen
Palm Pre – QWERTY Slide Out
Although some find it hard to type on the iPhone’s virtual keyboard, many reviewers who have used a Palm Pre have said the keys are too small and hard for even small fingers and because there is no option for an on-screen keyboard it could be a problem.
iPhone 3GS – Up to 9 hours internet surfing, 10 hours of video, 30 hours of audio, 12 hours of 2G talk-time and 5 hours of 3G talk-time.
Palm Pre – Many report that the battery can wear down within a few hours so not good for business use.
Although the Pre’s battery issue’s could be changed currently at the length it lasts it’s not a contender for business users who need the battery to last all day.
iPhone 3GS – 500,000
Palm Pre – 12
As of current, also pointed out at WWDC yesterday, the Palm Pre only has 12 apps for the device, however an app store is in beta at this time so this might change. It’s not fair to compare the phones on app store at this time as the iPhone didn’t have one for a while and the Palm Pre’s just come out.
iPhone 3GS – 3.5-inch (diagonal) widescreen Multi-Touch display, 480-by-320-pixel resolution at 163 ppi.
Palm Pre – 3.1-inch touch screen with a vibrant 24-bit color 320×480 resolution HVGA display.
The iPhone screen is in fact larger than the Pre, but many say the Pre looks more vibrant.
- Show off factor, Yes I know in the comments you’ve said how people shouldn’t be impressed by phones but in a lot of cases if you pull out an iPhone people around you want to play on it, not making it any better of a phone but just one of the things that come with the iPhone.
- iTunes, Yes both devices can sync with iTunes, however the Pre needs a bit of hacking to get it to work, but it provides an instant place for iPhone users to rent and download movies and TV shows along with buying music wherever they go.
I’m not saying the Palm Pre isn’t going to challenge the iPhone, of that I’m sure it will but I think that until they sort out the problems at launch, video recording and the app store and it’s battery life, it can’t become a true iPhone competitor.
3 thoughts on “Palm Pre, iPhone Killer? Not Quite. Part 2”
Well written post, the internet tends to be full of garbage these days, so good work and keep giving out useful content.
Sure, you forgot to mention that the iPhone can explode. Lovely feature. But not fun if it happened to you… EU has ordered Apple to fix it now or they will be banned in Europe.
You do realise than any device with a battery in can explode?
Many laptops explode and phones, it’s because it’s made by Apple that it gathers so much media attention.
Just because some iPhones have exploded, it doesn’t make it worse a phone. Also you don’t know how the devices were kept and under what circumstances caused the fault.
It’s not good that some devices have caught fire but it’s a problem with the battery technology used not the devices fault.